These two people now stuck in one home, married, and to Norma Jean, stuck together under one roof. Get your custom essay sample. The end of many lives, the end of the war, they use this place as a commemoration of a battle that ended in death and the end of many people. A Journal of the Arts in the South Bachelor’s or higher degree. The sad feelings brought back, all to pay her back for seeing her smoking.

Where a place was the end for so many, it will also be the end of her and the end of her relationship. Ironically, however, in the middle of their picnic lunch, Norma Jean tells Leroy that she wants to leave him. Norma Jean, did she give up? Rather than create a bond, a renewed intimacy between him and Norma Jean, his presence ironically produces their complete estrangement. I feel that this is significance to how she ends everything. However, since Mabel, in each of the three previous family structures, has unilaterally and imperialistically wielded the phallus to ensure her power, privilege, and wholeness, we can only imagine that she would carry the pattern into the fourth family structure as well, for her fantasy-fetish defines her subjectivity and her positionality; they are the elements that constitute her desire and identification.

Leroy Moffitt injured his leg in a highway accident and was home maaon since he was unable to drive his tractor-trailer. At the end of the trip to Shiloh and at the end of the story—which are both her trip and her story–Mabel remains a desiring subject—and a subject of desire.

essay on shiloh by bobbie ann mason

Because she has lost her positionality within the dominant fiction and because she has lost her sense of wholeness, Mabel psychically becomes nothing and lives nowhere, but since every subject lives its desire from someplace, and it articulates its position by means of fantasy, the scene within which desire is staged concerns itself with the placement of the subject.


Norma Jean’s husband was the kind of husband who was never home, but at random shkloh here and there, when he was passing by from trips driving his truck. This place could represent a number of different things, but I feel that it mean an end. Did she do what many thought she did, jump to her death?

essay on shiloh by bobbie ann mason

Then you have the husband, what does he mean to her now? Before he started truck driving he had bough Norma Jean and organ for Christmas. Bachelor’s or higher degree.

Shiloh by Bobbie Ann Mason Essay Example For Students | Artscolumbia

She used to go to bed with the chickens. This family, too, however, is not quite as normative or as unified as it first appears.

Not maybe because she wants bobbir die, but knowing that she has nothing more to look forward, but the reality of the end.

For the psyche, fantasy possesses all the power and truth-value of actuality Silverman The Ecco Press, The sad feelings brought back, all to pay her back for seeing her smoking.

Just as she blamed Leroy for her loss of Norma Jean—and thus her place in the first family structure—Mabel blames Norma Jean for her loss of Randy—and thus the loss of her place in the second family structure. She was content with this, well in reality she grew to having absolutely no problems with his line of work, until the shi,oh came. Her subjectivity—her positionality vis-a-vis the family structure–is secure, clear, and adequate.


The Return to Shiloh: Family and Fantasy in Bobbie Ann Mason’s “Shiloh”

So when her mother Mabel finds out, she mentions the one thing that would cause a reaction out of Norma Jean. The story ends when she turns back to Leroy and waves her arms. In order to do so, she has resorted to two of the conventional masculine strategies to cover over her castration: That is, Mabel desires Norma Jean and Leroy to travel to Shiloh because the trip embodies her imaginary return to it, a fantasy that not only represents the unity of the family for her, but one that also signifies her own unity and adequacy—the wholeness and sufficiency of her subjectivity.


The next day, Mabel and Jet visited the battleground, and then Norma Jean was born Over 30 successfully finished orders.

These two people now stuck in one home, married, and to Norma Jean, stuck together under one roof. Because of his wound, Leroy is forced to stay at home. Norma Jean, did she give up? I feel eighteen again. This a place of a civil war battlefield. Norma Jean and Leroy marry because Norma Jean gets pregnant, a fact that not only shames Mabel but one that she entirely blames on Leroy.

The Return to Shiloh: Family and Fantasy in Bobbie Ann Mason’s “Shiloh”

In a reverie about the battle at Shiloh, Leroy thinks: Presses universitaires d’Angers Support: Selected Stories of Bobbie Ann Mason. Male Subjectivity at the Margins.

essay on shiloh by bobbie ann mason

If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email. This relationship of the individual to the family, moreover, has fairly recently become the primary focus of psychoanalytic semiotics, most notably in the work of Kaja Silverman. For Mabel, the loss of her positionality within the first two family structures constitutes a form of castration.